Altar Music

A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

Should Music during an altar call be live? Why/Why Not?

Piano only.
8
28%
Full Band (Instruments only)
1
3%
Full Worship Team & Band
9
31%
Pre Selected Canned CD/Tape
2
7%
Other
9
31%
 
Total votes: 29

User avatar
EagerBeaver
--== J2 ==--
Posts: 4706
Joined: September 5th, 2003, 5:05 pm
Location: USA,Missouri
Contact:

Postby EagerBeaver » September 30th, 2008, 6:13 pm

Gerald Creasy wrote:Altar music is the tradition I despise more than any other.

Lets make it loud and maudlin....something to psychologically manipulate the people.

Have someone bleat out something like "I was Young, I had plenty of time!!" to work on the youngsters hearts.

What is the purpose? To entertain those not praying and to manipulate the suggestable.


I can somewhat agree with this assessment, though most of me still thinks altar music is a good thing to have.

At a camp I staffed back in '07, the keyboardist was playing the music so loud during prayer that after I walked on the stage and discreetly asked her to please tone it down a bit, the tongues quieted down too...hmmmm...
Chris Brewer - My Website

Gerald Creasy

Re: So...

Postby Gerald Creasy » October 1st, 2008, 2:08 am

Pastor Gary wrote:
Gerald Creasy wrote:Altar music is the tradition I despise more than any other.

Lets make it loud and maudlin....something to psychologically manipulate the people.

Have someone bleat out something like "I was Young, I had plenty of time!!" to work on the youngsters hearts.

What is the purpose? To entertain those not praying and to manipulate the suggestable.


So, are you suggesting that there should never be any element of emotion in our services? Are you of the opinion that the only valid decision is a purely intellectual one devoid of an emotional component?

We don't even buy automobiles or shampoo that way.
I hope the music we pick is not emotional manipulation, but if you perceive that creating a receptive frame of mind and atmosphere by singing a song that reminds people of God's grace and love for them is manipulation, then I guess so.

Last Sunday, as people prayed one for another, the band sang this...
Show me Your ways
That I may walk with You
Show me Your ways
I put my hope in You

The cry of my heart
Is to love You more
To live with the
Touch of Your hand
Stronger each day
Show me Your ways


Emotional manipulation or affirmation of our desire to walk with God?



Are you saying that there never has been emotional manipulation (whether consciously or not)???

Are you saying that a commitment to God in the fit of an emotional moment is as good as a commitment from resolve and understanding?

Gerald Creasy

Postby Gerald Creasy » October 1st, 2008, 2:16 am

EagerBeaver wrote:I can somewhat agree with this assessment, though most of me still thinks altar music is a good thing to have.

At a camp I staffed back in '07, the keyboardist was playing the music so loud during prayer that after I walked on the stage and discreetly asked her to please tone it down a bit, the tongues quieted down too...hmmmm...



I can not count the times that I have been unable to concentrate on a prayer because of the bleating of an "Altar call" singer.

And i will go to my grave remembering the kid at camp -distraught in the altar that could not pray and I had to yell in his ear to even get him to hear me the NOISE was so loud (I finally took him out and we had a seesion of talking and prayer in relative silence -we could hear each other).


What's wrong with SILENCE, motivating introspective thinking and reverence for God???

Or just respect for those who may be distraught and seeking God in the altar??

Tell the people who want to gossip or talk about last nights game -while the music covers their banter-to get out if they're not going to participate and show some reverence to God with somberness.

User avatar
SBW
Needs a LIFE
Posts: 114
Joined: February 6th, 2004, 4:42 am
Location: USA,Mississippi
Contact:

Alter Music

Postby SBW » October 1st, 2008, 4:03 am

I voted Other. When the pastor feels it is the appropriate time, he signals us. We start out with soft piano, bass, and guitar. When he is completely finished giving the alter call, the vocalist will come in. Usually a soft, slow, worshipful song.

If alter service is going well, later the rest of the band usually joins in.

Our band is sensitive to the Spirit. Most of us have played together off and on for most of 30 years. We know when it needs to be soft, and when folks want some good foot stompers. I believe a God called musician can add to a service. The musician or singer should not be there to "show off" or be the star attraction.

Like others have mentioned, there is nothing worse than trying to pray, or help somebody in the alter, and having to screem over the band.
SBW

User avatar
soulsearcher
What's next?
Posts: 3375
Joined: August 29th, 2006, 5:35 am
Location: USA,Florida

Postby soulsearcher » October 1st, 2008, 4:52 am

Just to clarify my perspective.

"Altar Call" is the Invitation to accept Christ as Lord and Savior; a moment of serious magnitude where a person sees themselves in light of eternity.

Not to be confused with "Altar Service," where there is corporate and perhaps fervent prayer around the altar.

That being said, again IMHO, it is a distration for multiple musicians to assemble and play for the "Altar Call."

Dr. Ron
I like flapjacks.
Posts: 3688
Joined: December 14th, 2004, 10:53 am
Location: USA,Tennessee

Altar music

Postby Dr. Ron » October 1st, 2008, 5:11 am

Soulsearcher was my pianist for a long time.....World Challenge Singers.

I have had some experience in the area of Altar Calls....lol

I only use .............and always only use .......a piano , very softly, watching me.....most of the time it is my wife who has worked with me for 43 years.....

I do understand the "occasional use" of the full band and praise team for a special situation.

If you do not have a musician with a good grasp of "setting the mood" or following the spirit, then good soft canned music is best.

NEVER>>>>and I mean NEVER allow a bunch of musicians scattered all over the building to come forward to disrupt the flow.....
Dr. Ron

User avatar
kurt73
Ranking in the posts...
Ranking in the posts...
Posts: 294
Joined: February 20th, 2008, 5:58 am
Location: USA,Ohio

Postby kurt73 » October 1st, 2008, 5:27 am

Piano only most of the time. Like Ron said, no disrupting the flow of the Holy Ghost.
Acts 6:4 (KJV)
But we will give ourselves continually to prayer, and to the ministry of the word.

User avatar
Pastor Bill
---=== J2 ===---
Posts: 5168
Joined: February 3rd, 2003, 10:04 am
Location: USA,Kentucky
Contact:

Postby Pastor Bill » October 1st, 2008, 11:29 am

RamboPreacher wrote:other was my vote. cause it depends on the kind of altar call, and if it is a call to alter. :)

I have several MD's for this, and is instrumental and piano (midi) only. fast, med., slow, depending on context of service. and of course our band is ready to jump in as well, if called upon and appropriate. have even played best of WOW dvd's. so full-spectrum of mixed bag, again depending on the leading of the Holy Ghost and if the orator/pastor has a preference or request.


I agree on this, it really depends on the move of the spirit, but I prefer not to use canned music, it seems more disconnected, and is harder to follow the leading of the spirit (but then again I've never had a great sound person that did more than just put on a random CD.
"Why would God allow Hitler his chapter in history? Why would God send a whale to swallow Jonah or turn a woman into a pillar of salt? Surely there were other ways. But I'll leave the particular methods of God to God."
-Spoken by David Abraham, Showdown by Ted Dekker

User avatar
Pastor Bill
---=== J2 ===---
Posts: 5168
Joined: February 3rd, 2003, 10:04 am
Location: USA,Kentucky
Contact:

Postby Pastor Bill » October 1st, 2008, 11:38 am

Gerald Creasy wrote:Altar music is the tradition I despise more than any other.

Lets make it loud and maudlin....something to psychologically manipulate the people.

Have someone bleat out something like "I was Young, I had plenty of time!!" to work on the youngsters hearts.

What is the purpose? To entertain those not praying and to manipulate the suggestable.


No, that's not what it should be at least. But the music is helpful as most are not comfortable with silence, and many are shy about praying when someone might overhear.

The music being instrumental is good especially at the beginning, but even with words it doesn't have to be manipulative, just nicely tied to the message.
"Why would God allow Hitler his chapter in history? Why would God send a whale to swallow Jonah or turn a woman into a pillar of salt? Surely there were other ways. But I'll leave the particular methods of God to God."

-Spoken by David Abraham, Showdown by Ted Dekker

User avatar
Pastor Gary
Kahu Gary, Benevolent Dictator
Posts: 10475
Joined: January 28th, 2003, 9:03 pm
Location: USA,Hawaii
Contact:

Re: So...

Postby Pastor Gary » October 1st, 2008, 11:54 am

Gerald Creasy wrote:Are you saying that there never has been emotional manipulation (whether consciously or not)???

Nope. I have BEEN emotionally manipulated (not always with music) and have probably been guilty of doing it to others, though unintentionally. It has happened... it happens... it will continue to happen. To admit that is not a call to toss out the musical baby with the bathwater.

Gerald Creasy wrote:Are you saying that a commitment to God in the fit of an emotional moment is as good as a commitment from resolve and understanding?

I am suggesting you are setting up a false dichotomy. It is not EITHER an emotional commitment OR an commitment from intellectual assent, resolve and understanding: it is usually a complex, nuanced mixture of a dozen things, including those polar opposites, and the conviction of the Holy Spirit can take the form of an emotional tug or a mental epiphany. Or both. Or none of the above.
"God is excited to show you mercy. He rises to give you His compassion." (Isaiah 30:18)

"For surely, O LORD, you bless the righteous;
you surround them with your favor as with a shield." (Psalm 5:12)

Gerald Creasy

Re: So...

Postby Gerald Creasy » October 1st, 2008, 12:04 pm

Pastor Gary wrote:
Gerald Creasy wrote:Are you saying that there never has been emotional manipulation (whether consciously or not)???

Nope. I have BEEN emotionally manipulated (not always with music) and have probably been guilty of doing it to others, though unintentionally. It has happened... it happens... it will continue to happen. To admit that is not a call to toss out the musical baby with the bathwater.

Gerald Creasy wrote:Are you saying that a commitment to God in the fit of an emotional moment is as good as a commitment from resolve and understanding?

I am suggesting you are setting up a false dichotomy. It is not EITHER an emotional commitment OR an commitment from intellectual assent, resolve and understanding: it is usually a complex, nuanced mixture of a dozen things, including those polar opposites, and the conviction of the Holy Spirit can take the form of an emotional tug or a mental epiphany. Or both. Or none of the above.



I do not see where I have set up an either or anything. I expressed my preferences and problems and even hindrances to ministry which sometimes occurs with the traditional way of Altar Call or Altar service music: LOUD and manipulative.

I would like to see a service of reverence and silence ATTEMPTED once in a while.

If music is used, use it wisely and sanely and NOT with high melodrama or You-could-get-hit-by-a-car-on-the-way-home psychomanipulation.

User avatar
Billy n NC
Moderator
Posts: 2694
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 8:39 am
Location: USA,NorthCarolina
Contact:

Postby Billy n NC » October 1st, 2008, 12:08 pm

soulsearcher wrote:Just to clarify my perspective.

"Altar Call" is the Invitation to accept Christ as Lord and Savior; a moment of serious magnitude where a person sees themselves in light of eternity.

Not to be confused with "Altar Service," where there is corporate and perhaps fervent prayer around the altar.

That being said, again IMHO, it is a distration for multiple musicians to assemble and play for the "Altar Call."


I agree on this statement. Should have made the difference in the orignial post. Altar Call vs Altar Service.

I have found it to be such a distraction for multiple muscians to come up, especiall from all over the church as Pastor Ron mentions in his post. And then your piano player drops the song book on the keys. (accidents do happen) or the drummer bumps into the cymbal or drops the sticks and the string instrument guy turns on or plugs in his instrument and AHHHHHH happens..

These are the kind of thing that leads me to the Canned CD/Tape instrumental music. and yes I know boo boos happen with these also. Too loud to start or wrong song. :oops:

Now a good altar call would be .

House lights dim.
Stage lights dim
Podium spot comes up. glowingly
Fog starts creeping across the stage.
Pastor starts talking in God like voice

ahhhh Naaaaa to much drama.
Billy Broach
Ebroach Services
http://www.ebroach.net/mediatech/

Bringing Media Technologies to God's Church Familes

Skype Name is ebroachnnc AIM is broachb

User avatar
paul
I can see clearly now!
Posts: 2749
Joined: May 17th, 2006, 7:10 pm
Location: USA,California
Contact:

Re: Band

Postby paul » October 1st, 2008, 12:24 pm

So nice to have so many different choices. The last several alter calls I gave. were in the open air...no music, just an invitation to come to Christ.
While I enjoy the opportunity to set "the mood" with music...I have come to learn it really is not necessary when the Holy Spirit is doing the drawing.

But still nice to have :lol:
You cannot effectively love and minister to others when you are obsessed with protecting
and preserving yourself.

User avatar
EagerBeaver
--== J2 ==--
Posts: 4706
Joined: September 5th, 2003, 5:05 pm
Location: USA,Missouri
Contact:

Re: So...

Postby EagerBeaver » October 1st, 2008, 12:36 pm

Gerald Creasy wrote:If music is used, use it wisely and sanely and NOT with high melodrama or You-could-get-hit-by-a-car-on-the-way-home psychomanipulation.


Well, I've got plenty of time, you know. :)
Chris Brewer - My Website

Gerald Creasy

Re: Band

Postby Gerald Creasy » October 1st, 2008, 12:43 pm

paul wrote:I have come to learn it really is not necessary when the Holy Spirit is doing the drawing.


Exactly


Return to “Jude 2 General Discussion Forum”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 21 guests

Login  •  Register