I've traveled in Gospel groups about 10 years & I'm also of the same notion as Billy - I greatly prefer having the mixer & power amps separate. If something goes wrong - it gives you a lot more options to work with.
We've loved the Peavey power amps (partial to the CS 800 & 1200 amps). We've only had 1 of those give us problems & it turned out to be a loose ribbon wire? We've beat & banged them around & they have been die hards!
We had 1 Peavy mixer & hated it. The sliders kept getting dust in them and would crackle when adjusting (actually before we got rid of it - we'd have to turn the sliders all the way up to "pop" them in each time we used it.) Newer models may be better - but that one was the pits.
We had a Mackie mixer for awhile & liked it pretty well. We bought a larger mixer a couple years ago & at that time everyone told us to go with Allen & Heath (which operates pretty similar to the Mackie). So far we've really liked it & it's given us absolutely no problems.
We also tried some Mackie powered speakers - and I can say those things were possessed of the devil! We may have just had a bad experience - but we had nothing but trouble with them. We go to a lot of older churches, country churches, etc. that at times have voltage problems, wiring problems, etc. because of their age, etc. & those things were very particular about their power requirements! We still laugh about it - but we actually had smoke come out of a cable connection once when the system wasn't even powered up (must have been a ground problem?) That was the day we got rid of them!
