Postby dolfan » June 2nd, 2008, 9:33 am
My great-great grandfather fought for the Confederacy as part of the Georgia 22nd Infantry and was shot in the Battle of Seven Pines, and survived, then moved later to Alabama. Anyone who reads the speeches of southern politicians during that time knows that they were not just a bunch of slaveowning wretches. These were people who, although they owned slaves (and there were as many northern slaveowners), were passionate about the limited role of the federal government and its imposition on the sovereignty of the individual states. The people in the Union Army and the ones in the Confederate Army were often brothers, cousins, friends, people with long histories as comrades. Only as secession, and then war, became inevitable, did the most hateful of the rhetoric spew en masse. I don't hate my southern history for having fought the war. It may be that one day, along different lines, that another revolt must happen to preserve our liberties and limit the government's imposition of itself. But, I do acknowledge this: We lost. We rejoined the Union. For that reason, I only acknowledge one flag, the American flag, and I simply (personally) reject the display of the Confederate flag except for in limited, small places where it is historically fit (i.e., on headstones of Civil War soldiers who fought for the South). It never, ever serves any real benefit to do it. There are many other ways of honoring the valor of the men who fought in that war.
PLUS, IMO, when our nation is at war with foreign powers as we are now, it is the wrong message to dredge up domestic rivalries of past centuries and attempt to distinguish any part of our national heritage from any other part around that particular war. We are one nation, under God. I wish the folks who, no matter how historical their intent, would display the Confederate flag in public places, would consider the feelings of people in Iraq and Afghanistan who are from, say, Illinois, and are putting their lives on the line for us southerners today. I'm sure those guys would object to it, and I just personally wish these SCV guys would let this go.
Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).