Postby dolfan » July 16th, 2008, 5:23 am
While I'm all for profit, mind you, I don't mean that the oil companies are blameless or somehow beyond criticism. They've done very well in all of this speculation, and only when their chairmen get subpoenaed to testify before Congress do they start harping about the lack of new refineries and inability to drill offshore, etc. I'm not convinced at all that the oil companies are populist (nor should they be). I don't think that ExxonMobil, for example, is my buddy. I think it is robbing me blind, but I also acknowledge that it is a legal robbery.
One problem is the Commodity Futures Trading Commission that regulates futures markets in the U.S. They're investigating the possibility that speculators are driving the market up, but they are taking six months to do it and they come into it with a bias against that conclusion. Their own chief economist testified to Congress a couple of months ago that the real problem was an imbalance of supply and demand and the weak dollar. I'll give you that the dollar is weak, no doubt. Weak enough to double the cost of oil? No, not yet.
The acting chairman of the CFTC testified just this past week that its role is one of "surveillance" for particular speculators (what he called "traders of size") trying to manipulate the market. Apparently, if they're all doing the same thing, it doesn't matter --- it's just the market, now matter how irrational it is. Then, true to his bureaucratic bent, he blamed the ineffectiveness of the CFTC to do more on being underbudgeted and understaffed.
"We stink at really doing anything helpful, but we could be better stinkers if you'd hire more of us and pay us more." Right.
Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).