Can you be a christian if......

A free-wheeling forum for discussion of Christian issues.

Moderators: Pastor Gary, The J2 Mod Squad

User avatar
Brian
Da Bomb!
Posts: 944
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 7:30 pm
Location: USA,Virginia

Can you be a christian if......

Postby Brian » October 9th, 2008, 2:45 pm

Now that I have your attention.....a more proper question would be "would a believer, a christian who proclaims Christ and is living out there life as best as they know how, could that believer NOT believe that the bible is entirely true and still be considered a follower of Christ? I don't mean someone who has never heard of the bible or someone who lives in a part of the world where christianity is all but forbidden and to openly follow Christ may cost you your life. I'm speaking of an educated middled aged middle income red blooded American with every opportunity to study and research the scriptures yet still out and out dismisses a large portion of the bible because they think it's been tampered with, altered, mistranslated, or other. Would that person still be acting and walking in God's will?

Just a few examples of the type of things I am refering to.
(for the sake of the discussion I will call him Jim)
Jim doesnt believe it when the bible said that "Godly men carried out executions on behalf of God"
ie. Ex. 32: 26 then Moses stood in the gate of the camp and said, “Who is on the Lord's side? Come to me.” And all the sons of Levi gathered around him. 27 And he said to them, “Thus says the Lord God of Israel, ‘Put your sword on your side each of you, and go to and fro from gate to gate throughout the camp, and each of you kill his brother and his companion and his neighbor.’” 28 And the sons of Levi did according to the word of Moses. And that day about three thousand men of the people fell.
Jim in under the impression that God would not tell people "Thou shall not kill (murder) and then tell these to kill.

Jim also doesn't believe that Jesus is God. He said that Jesus was created by God and that Jesus is "less than" God because of the scripture that says the Father is greated than I. John 14:28
I believe this verse to mean that as a man Jesus operated as a man and therefore His office was lower yet He was still fully God.

I am not trying to nit pik. i think these things are very VERY important. For me, this situation is one of consern for Jim. not to be right or prove him wrong.

Any thoughts?
"My eyes are ever on the Lord, for only He will release my feet from the snare." Psalm 25:15

http://www.myspace.com/twiztidstr8

User avatar
Pastor Gary
Kahu Gary, Benevolent Dictator
Posts: 10475
Joined: January 28th, 2003, 9:03 pm
Location: USA,Hawaii
Contact:

Re: Can you be a christian if......

Postby Pastor Gary » October 9th, 2008, 3:28 pm

Brian wrote:Jim also doesn't believe that Jesus is God. He said that Jesus was created by God and that Jesus is "less than" God because of the scripture that says the Father is greated than I. John 14:28
I believe this verse to mean that as a man Jesus operated as a man and therefore His office was lower yet He was still fully God.

That one is, for me, a deal-breaker.
"God is excited to show you mercy. He rises to give you His compassion." (Isaiah 30:18)

"For surely, O LORD, you bless the righteous;
you surround them with your favor as with a shield." (Psalm 5:12)

crispfin
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1870
Joined: September 11th, 2004, 8:00 am
Location: USA,Texas

Re: Can you be a christian if......

Postby crispfin » October 9th, 2008, 3:46 pm

Brian wrote:Now that I have your attention.....a more proper question would be "would a believer, a christian who proclaims Christ and is living out there life as best as they know how, could that believer NOT believe that the bible is entirely true and still be considered a follower of Christ? I don't mean someone who has never heard of the bible or someone who lives in a part of the world where christianity is all but forbidden and to openly follow Christ may cost you your life. I'm speaking of an educated middled aged middle income red blooded American with every opportunity to study and research the scriptures yet still out and out dismisses a large portion of the bible because they think it's been tampered with, altered, mistranslated, or other. Would that person still be acting and walking in God's will?

Jim also doesn't believe that Jesus is God. He said that Jesus was created by God and that Jesus is "less than" God because of the scripture that says the Father is greated than I. John 14:28
I believe this verse to mean that as a man Jesus operated as a man and therefore His office was lower yet He was still fully God.


First: Is the belief that the Bible is absolutely true in the sense you seem to be implying (no mistakes, no errors) an integral part of being a Christian? To be a true follower must one really harbor absolutely no doubts or questions?

Two:You seem to assume that if one is"an educated middled aged middle income red blooded American with every opportunity to study and research the scriptures" they would arrive at your view of the Bible. Is it not possible for someone who fits this criteria to honestly come to a different conclusion?

Three: You ask, "Would that person still be acting and walking in God's will?" It depends. If that person is being honest with their beliefs and still has a desire to follow Christ is this not an instance where we have to trust the Spirit to really guide them into all truth? I think it would be wrong for them to claim a belief they don't really have. I believe God's will would be for them to still seek Him even with their doubts.

Fourth: If someone believes your example as Jesus as a creation, then they would not be a Christian in the traditional sense, but their beliefs would actually be closer to Arius an early Christian heresiarch. Could such a person still be on their journey with God and eventually led to believe in Christ as God? Yes, I believe the Spirit can lead them and their Christian family can help too. But as for now, they would not traditionally (or in my opinion) be viewed as a Christian.

I believe in all of the cases I pointed out the person can still sincerely be trying to follow Christ, albeit imperfectly. But whose walk is not? They may not fit into our conception of a Christian, but I'd rather see them as someone still searching than just people who are wrong.

User avatar
Brian
Da Bomb!
Posts: 944
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 7:30 pm
Location: USA,Virginia

Re: Can you be a christian if......

Postby Brian » October 9th, 2008, 4:24 pm

Pastor Gary wrote:
Brian wrote:Jim also doesn't believe that Jesus is God. He said that Jesus was created by God and that Jesus is "less than" God because of the scripture that says the Father is greated than I. John 14:28
I believe this verse to mean that as a man Jesus operated as a man and therefore His office was lower yet He was still fully God.

That one is, for me, a deal-breaker.


Yea Pastor Gary, that one is a BIG one for me as well! :shock:

I don't want to get in the habit of picking and choosing who is or isn't a "real" christian. I am no where near being able to make such a call. However, I must admit that to me, thereare certain things that I believe would eliminate someone from holding such a title if not accepted and believed. The bible tells us that all we need to do in believe upon Christ to be saved. However, the demons believe and tremble yet they have no salvation. I am more inclinded to see it as if someone believes upon the Jesus proclaimed throughout the scriptures one would obtain salvation. Would that be to far off the mark?
Would it be safe to asume that if I believe in a Jesus that is not reveiled in the scriptures then I am not believing in the "real" Jesus?

For the record, I am not asking these questions to set up some sort of prerequisite in order for someone to be a christian. As if any of us merit the right to be called one. :wink:
I believe that we are saved by grace through faith and not of ourselves. But I do think that within the confines of our faith one must believe upon the Lord that is explained and declared in the bible.

Thanks PG
"My eyes are ever on the Lord, for only He will release my feet from the snare." Psalm 25:15



http://www.myspace.com/twiztidstr8

User avatar
Brian
Da Bomb!
Posts: 944
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 7:30 pm
Location: USA,Virginia

Re: Can you be a christian if......

Postby Brian » October 9th, 2008, 4:40 pm

crispfinagin wrote:First: Is the belief that the Bible is absolutely true in the sense you seem to be implying (no mistakes, no errors) an integral part of being a Christian? To be a true follower must one really harbor absolutely no doubts or questions?


I personally believe that believing in the inerrancy of the scriptures is very important to the christian. Is it nescessary for salvation? I can't say. But I would like to think that a follower of Christ would believe that the written testamony about our Lord and Savour would be an important tool in the progression of there walk with God.

Two:You seem to assume that if one is"an educated middled aged middle income red blooded American with every opportunity to study and research the scriptures" they would arrive at your view of the Bible. Is it not possible for someone who fits this criteria to honestly come to a different conclusion?


Absolutely! I have no wish to turn everyones thinking into "my" thinking. The body is very diverse and has many different ministries and functions. many of those will naturally be outside of what I may understand or even possibly agree with. But to keep it in perspective I was talking more along the line of someone who rejects the scripture outrite and being either wrong, or lies, or manipulation. Not merely a difference of understanding, rather a rejection of established truth. (not "my" truth) :)

Three: You ask, "Would that person still be acting and walking in God's will?" It depends. If that person is being honest with their beliefs and still has a desire to follow Christ is this not an instance where we have to trust the Spirit to really guide them into all truth? I think it would be wrong for them to claim a belief they don't really have. I believe God's will would be for them to still seek Him even with their doubts.


Agreed. It is definately better to travel the road than to get off of it. :)

Fourth: If someone believes your example as Jesus as a creation, then they would not be a Christian in the traditional sense, but their beliefs would actually be closer to Arius an early Christian heresiarch. Could such a person still be on their journey with God and eventually led to believe in Christ as God? Yes, I believe the Spirit can lead them and their Christian family can help too. But as for now, they would not traditionally (or in my opinion) be viewed as a Christian.

I believe in all of the cases I pointed out the person can still sincerely be trying to follow Christ, albeit imperfectly. But whose walk is not? They may not fit into our conception of a Christian, but I'd rather see them as someone still searching than just people who are wrong.


Again I agree. There journey could most definately lead them to the truth of God and His will for there lives.

Thanks for your questions and input. God bless
"My eyes are ever on the Lord, for only He will release my feet from the snare." Psalm 25:15



http://www.myspace.com/twiztidstr8

crispfin
Hey, hey, hey
Posts: 1870
Joined: September 11th, 2004, 8:00 am
Location: USA,Texas

Re: Can you be a christian if......

Postby crispfin » October 9th, 2008, 5:16 pm

Brian wrote:
I personally believe that believing in the inerrancy of the scriptures is very important to the christian. Is it nescessary for salvation? I can't say. But I would like to think that a follower of Christ would believe that the written testamony about our Lord and Savour would be an important tool in the progression of there walk with God.

I agree with your perspective on the scriptures. As far as a necessity of salvation goes, I had in my my grandfather who was not converted until just before his death. For him, as for many others throughout history, his only concern was in Christ as his savior. Nothing else was important to him. But I believe for us to live out our relationship with God the scriptures are an infallible guide.

[/quote]Absolutely! I have no wish to turn everyones thinking into "my" thinking. The body is very diverse and has many different ministries and functions. many of those will naturally be outside of what I may understand or even possibly agree with. But to keep it in perspective I was talking more along the line of someone who rejects the scripture outrite and being either wrong, or lies, or manipulation. Not merely a difference of understanding, rather a rejection of established truth. (not "my" truth)[/quote]

If one rejects the scripture outright and views it as, at best, highly suspect, then I think the Christ they create to follow will have more to do with their preferences than with anything the Bible would present. Their God would be created in their image, and more like their imaginary friend than their Lord. :)

[/quote]Again I agree. There journey could most definately lead them to the truth of God and His will for there lives.

Thanks for your questions and input. God bless
[quote]
God bless you as well!

User avatar
Poimen
What's next?
Posts: 3403
Joined: February 10th, 2003, 1:49 pm
Location: USA, Alabama

Postby Poimen » October 9th, 2008, 5:35 pm

Jim certainly has some heretical ideas, however I don't know that they necessarily prevent him from being saved, at least intially. There is a difference in heresy and damnable heresy (IMO).

Let me ask this, does he believe Jesus is the unique son of God? Does he believe Jesus thus shares divinity in that respect with the Father, and thus the holy, righteous, perfect nature of the Father?

Does he believe Christ, the Son of God, was a perfectly sinless man, whose death is the only grounds for propitiation?

Does he believe that Christ physically arose from the grave, ascended into heaven, and there awaits till His return at the end of the age? Does He believe Christ's ressurection is the only basis for the hope of eternal life?

Does he believe that only by placing trust in the person, merit, and work of Christ he receive the benefit of the atonement to himself? That is that he is saved by grace through faith in Christ alone? not of works?

If so, then I believe he has sufficient truth to believe on Christ as Lord and savior, and would then be a true believer.

But that's just me. :)
Poimen
Bro. Christopher

"I wish a buck was still silver, it was back when the country was strong." -- The Hag

User avatar
dolfan
Established Member
Posts: 8016
Joined: March 17th, 2004, 1:25 pm
Location: USA,Alabama
Contact:

Postby dolfan » October 9th, 2008, 5:42 pm

I'll suspend judgment on Jim, but in my opinion, he is not a believer. I'll say that a lot more of his views of Christ would be revealed if you learned how he views himself. And, that, IMO is best (as far as I've ever seen) revealed in the Ray Comfort/Kirk Cameron evangelism method.
Human government bears the same relation to hell as the church bears to heaven. (David Lipscomb, On Civil Government, 72).

jessea
Needs a LIFE
Posts: 149
Joined: April 9th, 2004, 3:02 am
Location: O'Fallon, MO

Postby jessea » October 9th, 2008, 6:10 pm

I think the question is not whether or not he is a believer, the question should be, "is he born again?"

There are a lot of people who attend churches all across America who believe in God. Nicodemus told Jesus "I know that you are from God, for no one can do these things unless God was with him"

Jesus didn't tell Nicodemus that what he believed about Him would be his salvation, he instead told him, "you must be born again, or you will not see the kingdom of God"

Born again people see the gospel not as controversial, but as the power of God.


1 Corinthians 1:18

"For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God ."

User avatar
Brian
Da Bomb!
Posts: 944
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 7:30 pm
Location: USA,Virginia

Postby Brian » October 9th, 2008, 6:28 pm

My words in bold.


Poimen wrote:Jim certainly has some heretical ideas, however I don't know that they necessarily prevent him from being saved, at least intially. There is a difference in heresy and damnable heresy (IMO).

Let me ask this, does he believe Jesus is the unique son of God? Yes Does he believe Jesus thus shares divinity in that respect with the Father, and thus the holy, righteous, perfect nature of the Father? Thats a bit harder to answer. From my perspective (which could be flawed) I would say that Jim believes that God made Christ and is His Father and the Father gave Christ all power and authority. But I can't say for sure if he see's Christ divinely equal to God the Father.

Does he believe Christ, the Son of God, was a perfectly sinless man, whose death is the only grounds for propitiation?As best as I understand him, yes.

Does he believe that Christ physically arose from the grave, ascended into heaven, and there awaits till His return at the end of the age?Yes Does He believe Christ's ressurection is the only basis for the hope of eternal life?This one again is tricky. While Jim says that he personally doesn't think anyone other than Christ can lead the christian to God, he leaves room for the possibility that that "truth" could be subject to error. In other words he thinks possibly that Buddists have access to God through Buddism. That Hindu's have access to God through Hinduism, and the same for other belief systems and that no one can know for sure until we die and stand before God.

Does he believe that only by placing trust in the person, merit, and work of Christ he receive the benefit of the atonement to himself? For himself? Yes That is that he is saved by grace through faith in Christ alone? not of works? Combination of faith and works together.

If so, then I believe he has sufficient truth to believe on Christ as Lord and savior, and would then be a true believer.

But that's just me. :)

Thanks Piomen. Its tough sometimes on how to properly communicate with people who has such a vastly different view of the scriptures without making them feel like I was trying to force my views or beliefs on them. I am not. Anyway....thanks Piomen, God bless.
"My eyes are ever on the Lord, for only He will release my feet from the snare." Psalm 25:15



http://www.myspace.com/twiztidstr8

User avatar
Poimen
What's next?
Posts: 3403
Joined: February 10th, 2003, 1:49 pm
Location: USA, Alabama

Postby Poimen » October 9th, 2008, 6:35 pm

Brian,

There are so many contigencies I would almost have to be the one talking with Jim to really understand myself what he believes. However, I hope my position was clear enough to give you some food for thought.

As to his belief in salvation being a combination of faith and works, can you explain a bit further? Maybe give an exmaple? This could (for me) be a "deal breaker" as PG called it.

BTW, this guy sounds an aweful lot like a guy I know from another forum. If it is then tell the "Dude" I said "Yo." :lol:
Poimen
Bro. Christopher

"I wish a buck was still silver, it was back when the country was strong." -- The Hag

User avatar
Brian
Da Bomb!
Posts: 944
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 7:30 pm
Location: USA,Virginia

Postby Brian » October 9th, 2008, 6:38 pm

jessea wrote:Born again people see the gospel not as controversial, but as the power of God.

1 Corinthians 1:18
"For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God ."


That reminds me. Jim doesn't think the "cross" has anything to do with anything. He seems to view peoples apritiation of the cross as "worshipping the cross". And views it as just simply the execution method of the Romans and holds no significance in the life of the believer.

I know, it all together paints a picture as if I am talking bad about Jim. I PROMISE I AM NOT!! :) That is not my intention in any way whatsoever. I simply want to convey as best I can Jim's position on matters that he and I discussed.

God bless
"My eyes are ever on the Lord, for only He will release my feet from the snare." Psalm 25:15



http://www.myspace.com/twiztidstr8

User avatar
Poimen
What's next?
Posts: 3403
Joined: February 10th, 2003, 1:49 pm
Location: USA, Alabama

Postby Poimen » October 9th, 2008, 7:01 pm

Brian wrote:
That reminds me. Jim doesn't think the "cross" has anything to do with anything. He seems to view peoples apritiation of the cross as "worshipping the cross". And views it as just simply the execution method of the Romans and holds no significance in the life of the believer.

I know, it all together paints a picture as if I am talking bad about Jim. I PROMISE I AM NOT!! :) That is not my intention in any way whatsoever. I simply want to convey as best I can Jim's position on matters that he and I discussed.


Ewwwww ... that's NOT good. Does that mean he doesn't believe Jesus's death was and has to be a sacrifical death on our behalf? Or just on the cross?

Either way, that's giving me more keen perspective on his doubts and positions. IT is begining to sound more convicnvgly that he is acknowlding a version of Jesus he can accept and not the Jesus of Scripture. I hope it is not so, but I certainly understand your concern.

I feel confident I can say our prayers here are with you and your interaction with Jim -- for his soul's sake.
Poimen
Bro. Christopher

"I wish a buck was still silver, it was back when the country was strong." -- The Hag

User avatar
Brian
Da Bomb!
Posts: 944
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 7:30 pm
Location: USA,Virginia

Postby Brian » October 9th, 2008, 7:06 pm

dolfan wrote:And, that, IMO is best (as far as I've ever seen) revealed in the Ray Comfort/Kirk Cameron evangelism method.


Could you explain what you mean dolfan. I'm not familiar with Ray Comfort but I have watched Kirk Cameron many times. Do they operate with a "certain style" or "method" of evangelism? Sorry just wondering because any support or guideance as to how to witness and teach of the Lord is always welcome.

Thanks dolfan
"My eyes are ever on the Lord, for only He will release my feet from the snare." Psalm 25:15



http://www.myspace.com/twiztidstr8

User avatar
Mike Vande
I like flapjacks.
Posts: 3859
Joined: January 29th, 2003, 6:22 pm
Location: USA,Kansas

Postby Mike Vande » October 10th, 2008, 2:31 am

If the person was a brand new believer who just hadn't been taught better, there is at at least a possibility that he's a real Christian. If he continues in such a state of belief for any real length of time, I would think problems would eventually arise. The Holy Spirit is supposed to lead us into all truth, and sometimes it takes a while.
Why is it that bad decisions seem to make to most interesting testimonies?


Return to “Jude 2 General Discussion Forum”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 17 guests

Login  •  Register