I'm not even sure how to respond to this. But here goes, then I am done.
We will have to agree to dis-agree on most of this. I have asked for the specifics of the OT teachings. You don't seem to understand them yourself; or if you do, just chose to ignore them. Not everyone was required to tithe in the OT. So how you can apply it to everyone now, I'm not sure. I still believe that teaching a standard of giving is a good thing. It is when we put a number to it that it becomes legalism. You say you don't, but then say...
but in teaching tithing, I have seen some realize that the amount of their giving comes nowhere close, and through that God has led them to seek Him in their finances, leading them to financial freedom to give and give cheerfully
When you teach someone that tithing is a standard of giving, it gives them a structure they can apply to their budgeting, If they accept that teaching and learn to give freely from it, they can give cheerfully and fulfill what the Word says to do.
The only way to fulfill what the Word says then is to tithe, according to you. People can be taught to give sacrificially, cheerfully, etc. without teaching it that way. That is all I am saying. When we teach them that Jesus said to do it, or the OT said to do it, we are not being 100% truthful since it was not required of all; only of certain people at certain times AND required more than 10% annually in some cases. I only asked the OT requirements questions to get people to dig into what they really were. AND so someone could correct me on what they said if I missed something.
Where does it state that there are no standards? You ignore the fact that Christ mentioned tithing and called it good (because he was talking to people under the law but then again, weren't they all under the law at that time? Who else was he supposed to talk to? Christ saw this standard and called it good, where is there anything to say different?
There are allot of good things that Jesus told people to do. To take this further then would be to suggest that no one should give more than 10% because 10% is good as ordained by Jesus. You miss the point of what he said. Matt 23:23KJV - "Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye pay tithe of mint and anise and cummin, and have omitted the weightier matters of the law, judgment, mercy, and faith: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone." This is what he was saying... You ought to have kept the Law by tithing of your spices, but shame on you for leaving out judgement, mercy, and grace. To stretch that into a tithe for NT/post resurrection believers is really just not good theology or interpretation.
BUT I know many who struggle financially, they give very sparingly, and don't really seek God in that area of their lives. If asked, they believe they are cheerful givers, but honestly it is not seen in their life or their attitude.
I believe some aren't cheerful because they aren't able to hit the 10%, so they feel guilt. That guilt takes away the joy. That is what the letter of the Law does... even if it is taught as a standard or principle as you put it.
I have also seen people in the same situation embrace the message you are preaching and justify their unfaithfulness by claiming freedom from having to give.
Some people will find every loop hold they can to avoid doing the right thing. This is why discipleship is so important. Get people close to God, then He can lead them in these matters, instead of trying to live up to Laws that He freed them from.
I don't teach tithing to increase what comes into the church, I teach tithing to give God's people an understanding that God can do much more than they think, and challenging them to meet that standard opens their eyes to His faithfulness to see them through even when by their fears they did not feel they could afford to tithe.
The truth is that there are many who simply can not afford to tithe. I have outlined some of those in earlier posts. This does not have to also make them a sourpuss giver. They can still cheerfully give whatever they have and be a mature God fearing, God loving, NT sacrificial giver!!
I'm not teaching tithing as a burden, but I'm teaching it as a freedom from the financial burdens of this world. Maybe it's the fact that I live and minister in very poor communities and I have seen more bound up in these problems than the legalism you seem to feel runs rampant in my teaching, I'm not a legalistic person, and I have never been in my ministry.
Teaching people to become better stewards is always the right thing to do. Teaching them how to become debt free stewards is even better. Making both a reality for everyone is sadly just not possible. The poor will always be with us.
Some define legalism in different ways. I guess we must agree to dis-agree.
Peace!!

![Remember our veterans and troops currently serving today. [amer-ribbon90.gif]](/images/amer-ribbon90.gif)